Here's why Uncle Benjen's reunion with Jon Snow was so important in 'Game of Thrones' episode 6

UNCLE BEN?!
 By 
Jess Joho
 on 
Original image replaced with Mashable logo
Original image has been replaced. Credit: Mashable

Jon Snow just won't die on Game of Thrones. And the latest episode, "Beyond the Wall," provided us with the most convenient plot twist of all to save him.

Uncle Benjen's back!

Oh dear, now Uncle Benjen isn't back :(

But we're not all that sure Ben's final moments in the episode necessarily prove he's dead. Despite being mobbed by wights, there's a lot to suggest otherwise, actually.

First, though, let's do a refresher on who the hell Uncle Benjen even is in the first place, why his reunion with Jon was so meaningful, and what the it might mean for his role in the future.

Benjen was Ned Stark's youngest brother, who served as the "Stark in Winterfell" while all his brothers were off fighting in Robert's Rebellion. Almost immediately after Ned (his only surviving sibling) returned from the war, Benjen decided to go off and volunteer to join the Night's Watch.

That's a pretty nutty move for a nobleman with an important last name and promising future.

The reasons behind his decision were never made clear. But ever since his introduction in the first episode of the show in Season 1, Benjen was actually already trying to warn people about an ominous threat from beyond the Wall.

There was a strong connection between Benjen and Jon Snow from day one. Even with limited screen time, it was clear that he was Jon's hero growing up, serving as the noble and badass First Ranger of the Night's Watch. He gave Ned's bastard son something to aspire toward, and Jon never forgot it.

But their days of warm embraces in Winterfell were short-lived. Benjen returned to ranging beyond the Wall to find out more about what happened to his fellow brothers in black (who were murdered by the White Walkers in the very first scene of Season 1.)

Benjen never came back. His spooked horse did, but it was missing a rider.

Several seasons later, Jon's young steward Olly ran into his office to tell Lord Commander Snow that his Uncle Benjen had finally returned. But it was a trick. Instead of a family reunion, Jon got stabbed by his own brothers in black, in the mutiny that lead to his eventual resurrection.

Original image replaced with Mashable logo
Original image has been replaced. Credit: Mashable

This fake-out wasn't just a red herring, though. Benjen did come back -- to save a different Stark in Season 6. When Meera and Bran looked just as doomed as Jon, with a swarm of wights gaining on them after their attack on the cave, Benjen rode in with his ball of fire to save the day.

In yet another parallel to Jon, Benjen was also resurrected. He told Bran that after being killed by wights he was brought back by the Children of the Forest, who pierced his heart with dragonglass (similar to how they created the first White Walker ever). This somehow kept him from turning into a mindless zombie.

But the cost of his resurrection was to live out the rest of his undead days stuck in this strange, permanent purgatory, not quite dead, but no longer truly alive.

Importantly, Benjen also told Bran that he was not allowed to cross the Wall with them, because the same magical protections that kept the White Walkers from passing through it also applied to him.

As one redditor theorizes, this warning could have dire implications for everyone's plan to take a wight down South next episode:

But this also means that there's a pretty good chance Benjen will survive the fight he saved Jon from in episode 6.

Some even theorize that Benjen not only knows of Jon's true parentage (as Ned's only surviving sibling, it would make sense for him to trust Ben with that information), but that he might've even risked it all to save Jon because (like Melisandre) he believes Jon is Azor Ahai and the final hope for the living in the battle to come.

One redditor theorized that Benjen's uncanny timeliness in saving Jon might even tell us something huge about Bran:

Things have been quiet on the Bran front, so this advancement in his abilities might be exactly what he needs to become relevant again.

While Benjen has yet to return in the Song of Ice and Fire books, the Game of Thrones showrunners have often referred to the show version of Benjen as "Coldhands" (see the video below.)

In the books, Coldhands is another mysterious undead helper cloaked in black who saves Bran and Meera beyond the Wall. His identity has yet to be confirmed in A Song of Ice and Fire, and although some fans theorize that the book version of Coldhands is also Benjen, that has not yet been conclusively proven. (In fact, there's some evidence to contradict it.)

But even if book Coldhands is unrelated to Benjen, there's a lot of fascinating information in ASOIAF we can use as an indication of what might still lie ahead for Benjen on the show, if the showrunners are using that character as a template.

Like Benjen, Coldhands also wears a black Night's Watch uniform. Leaf (the Child of the Forest who helps Bran in the Three-Eyed Raven's cave) hints that, "they killed him long ago," leading many to believe Coldhands is actually the northern legend known as "the Night's King" (who, just to make things extra confusing, is also different from the "Night King" leader of the white walkers we've seen on the show.)

In the books, centuries ago, the Night's King served as the 13th Lord Commander. After joining in an "unholy union" with a "corpse Queen" (AKA what sounds suspiciously like having sex with a White Walker), he declared himself King, and subjected the Watch to a reign of terror that included human sacrifices.

It is theorized that, after finally being defeated and cast out from Castle Black, the Night's King became Coldhands -- an undead, fallen brother of the Night's Watch roaming the forests in search of redemption for betraying his brothers in black.

While this rad back history likely won't have any place on the show, it does lend credence to the theory that Benjen is kind of... unkillable now.

And, like Coldhands, Benjen has found purpose in his aimless, undead existence by committing himself to protecting his remaining family. (Oh, by the way, The Night's King was believed to be a Stark too!)

So, in all likelihood, we haven't seen the last of Uncle Ben. And we'll be glad for that if the Land of Always Winter spreads south once the Army of the Dead goes beyond the Wall.

As Benjen told Bran last season, “The great war is coming and I still fight for the living. I’ll do what I can as long as I can.”

Mashable Image
Jess Joho

Jess is an LA-based culture critic who covers intimacy in the digital age, from sex and relationship to weed and all media (tv, games, film, the web). Previously associate editor at Kill Screen, you can also find her words on Vice, The Atlantic, Rolling Stone, Vox, and others. She is a Brazilian-Swiss American immigrant with a love for all things weird and magical.

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
This robot snow blower is trending — and it's $400 off right now at Amazon
the yarbo robot snow blower removes snow in the dark while a home with a big window sits behind the robot. Inside, a family is looking outside while smiling.

Winter storm snowfall levels: See online how many inches have fallen nationwide
A man up to his waist in snow

'Pragmata' combines thrilling sci-fi action with endearing uncle energy
Hugh and Diana looking at a simulation of Times Square

Jon Stewart shares his blunt thoughts on Trump and Venezuela
A man sits behind a talk show desk looking unimpressed. In the top left is an image of the president.

Jon Stewart hits back at MAGA's reaction to Bad Bunny's Super Bowl halftime show
A man in a suit sits behind a talk show desk. In the top left is a screenshot of a Truth Social post.

More in Entertainment

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 3, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

Wordle today: Answer, hints for April 3, 2026
Wordle game on a smartphone

Google launches Gemma 4, a new open-source model: How to try it
Google Gemma


You can track Artemis II in real time as Orion flies to the moon
Victor Glover and Reid Wiseman piloting the Orion spacecraft
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!