Does Reworking Beatles' Song 'Hey Jude' Into a Minor Key Make It Better?

 By 
Charlie White
 on 
Does Reworking Beatles' Song 'Hey Jude' Into a Minor Key Make It Better?

What if the Beatles had lived in an alternative universe, and the group's 1968 megahit "Hey Jude" was not intended to cheer up John Lennon's son Julian, but to sound like a funeral dirge?

That's just what you'll get with this version of "Hey Jude," mashed down into a minor key that feels completely different, especially to those of us who've grown up with the Beatles and their groundbreaking music.

Its creator, apparently dipping into the wonders of Auto-Tune for this version he released in late January, agrees. He says on the video's YouTube page, "I reworked it to minor key, and it became almost entirely new song."

The mashup artist, whose group goes by the name "The Rumbeatles," might have taken an uplifting song and made it sadder.

He added, "Sad, beautiful, melancholic -- embodying what all of us feel about this outstanding phenomenon of The Beatles, and the fact that it will never happen again."

What say you, readers? Is this a desecration of one of the classic songs of all time, or a delightful reworking of "Hey Jude" into something new?

Mashable Image
Credit:

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!