Nickelodeon vs. Disney: The Ultimate '90s Showdown

 By   on 
Nickelodeon vs. Disney: The Ultimate '90s Showdown

Mac vs. PC? iPhone vs. Android? Democrat vs. Republican? These are big decisions, people.

But for a '90s kid, there was no decision more crucial than pledging allegiance to Nickelodeon or Disney Channel.

Nickelodeon aired dozens of beloved series throughout the '90s, including Rugrats, Hey Arnold, Rocket Power, All That, The Amanda Show and Clarissa Explains It All.

Disney's roster, though smaller, featured a strong rotation of Mickey Mouse Club, Flash Forward, Bug Juice, Off the Wall and The Baby-Sitters Club. Some might argue Disney's strongest shows actually extended outside of the Disney Channel, airing on networks like ABC or PBS. The channel was also famous for its original movies.

Which channel ultimately came out on top? We turn to GIFs from our favorite '90s shows to help us decide.

Nickelodeon aired 76 different shows over the course of the decade.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: PandaWhale

Disney aired 20 series during the same time period, including the uber-popular Mickey Mouse Club, where Justin Timberlake, J.C. Chasez, Britney Spears, Ryan Gosling and Christina Aguilera got their starts.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: britneyspearsgifs.blogspot.com

Some of Disney's biggest hits weren't originally by Disney: Boy Meets World was from ABC, Smart Guy was from WB, Bill Nye the Science Guy was from PBS and The New Adventures of Doug was based on the original Doug series from Nick.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, everytimeicomeinthekitchen

Nick's shows were original, and aired on one network.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, Kids in the '90s

Nick's programming was always light and fun, if totally bizarre.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, clarissa-sxe

Disney focused more strongly on relatable themes, like family, friendship and growing up.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: YouTube, BenW783a

Nick shows like Rugrats, Hey Arnold, and Rocket Power glorified being a kid, especially if you didn't have strong parental supervision.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, r4reland

But Disney shows dealt with more mature storylines that made growing up seem like the coolest thing ever.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: YouTube, hillybillyprofane

Even if you weren't quite ready to grow up just yet.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, joeyxparmenter

Both channels imparted crucial lessons about growing up. Clarissa Darling from Nick's Clarissa Explains It All was the big sister every '90s kid wished they had.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, peteneems

While Kristy, Mary-Anne, Claudia, Stacey, and Dawn set you straight on Disney's The Baby-Sitters Club.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, absurd noise

Nick's lineup in the afternoons featured mostly cartoons.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, itsheartacheeverymoment

Most of Disney's cartoons were based off of films and eventually syndicated onto other networks.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, bustygirlcomics

Every Nick fan's ultimate fantasy was to be a contestant on Figure It Out and get slimed.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Nick

And Disney fans wanted to compete in "The Head-to-Head Challenge" on Off the Wall.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: YouTube, gameshowkid

Even though both channels aimed to be somewhat educational...

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, fuckyeahbillnye

Disney's Bill Nye beat Nick's All That's "Everyday French with Pierre Escargot" every time.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, catpacks

Disney Channel Original Movies sparked a love of great film for all 90s kids-turned-film studies majors. They simply cannot be beat.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, frickyeah1990s

Of all the outrageous Disney Channel Original Movie plots, The Thirteenth Year, featuring a 13-year-old boy who transforms into a merman, was the coolest.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: YouTube, DisneyCzech

By contrast, Nick made an original movie called Cry Baby Lane about a pair of conjoined twins who get sawed in half and buried. It was considered too disturbing for children and only aired once. Not cool, guys.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, bbqdip

Kids of the early '90s grew up with the original Doug on Nick.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, Elora Borealis

After the show went off-air, Disney purchased the rights and re-aired it on both Disney and ABC throughout the late '90s.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, northgang

Nick's off-beat sense of humor was parent-friendly.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, the90swere-allthat

But few parents could make it through an overly-dramatic episode of So Weird.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: YouTube, WintersAngel6302

All in all, Nick ruled the '90s.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, m.j.t.

But don't sweat it Disney fans, you totally ruled the '00s.

Mashable Image
Credit:

Image: Tumblr, My Life Through Lizzie McGuire

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!