For years, the world has debated between who was the better boyfriend from Dawson's Creek? Pacey or Dawson? (Duh, it's Pacey.)
So Wednesday night, when Joey herself (Katie Holmes) was on The Late Late Show, James Corden attempted to pry some insider information out of her on each boy's kissing abilities. Joey's lips were sealed, but Ryan Reynolds had some important opinions of his own on the subject.
In unrelated anecdotes, Reynolds also shared how he recently had his very own Revenant moment when he accidentally stepped into a dead horse.