Apple shuts down screen limiting apps, but its own version is flawed
With Apple's iOS 12 arrival in September, iPhone users saw "Screen Time" features make their way to phone screens to counter-intuitively help them spend less time on their phones. But Apple's built-in phone addiction fighting tool isn't necessarily the best way to decrease screen time.
Although users could finally track phone and specific app usage while also limiting the amount of time spent on the phone and in apps, it didn't instantly eliminate the problem. For parents, it offered a way to manage kids' tech and connected time. The tool was a long time coming (Google's similar wellbeing tool for Android phones was available in Aug. 2018), but other apps had stepped up over the years to offer phone addicts and parents similar, yet often expanded, features.
A New York Times report Saturday found that 11 of the top third-party screen time and parental control apps have been removed from Apple's App Store or forced to change features. While that's concerning about Apple's power to destroy apps and businesses it views as competitors, it also weakens everyone's options for better phone control.
It almost feels like Apple's repeated line that "We don’t want people using their phones all the time," is as hollow as it sounds. Of course the company doesn't want users addicted to screens and unhealthily attached to their phones, but as the NYT report makes clear, it seems the iPhone maker is doing a lot to minimize your options around customizing phone usage.
Apple said in a statement online that it removed these apps because "they put users' privacy and security at risk." The company said the removed apps used a "highly invasive" technology called Mobile Device Management, or MDM.
"When we found out about these guideline violations, we communicated these violations to the app developers, giving them 30 days to submit an updated app to avoid availability interruption in the App Store," the statement read.
"Several developers released updates to bring their apps in line with these policies. Those that didn’t were removed from the App Store."
Now parents and compulsive phone users are limited to Apple's native tools, all dubbed "Screen Time." While for many it's a perfectly fine solution that reminds you to log off or look away, for others it's not as powerful as what third-party options once offered.
Some glaring issues immediately come up with Apple's Screen Time. Mostly that it's easy to get around the limits. Kids quickly figured out how to game the controls and get into YouTube or game apps that parents had restricted. For adults, time limits for social media apps or others require a lot of self-control. With just your passcode you can allow the phone to let you back onto Facebook all day if you want.
Another issue: for families, Screen Time requires the entire fam to have an iPhone. Other restriction apps gave parents the ability to manage their kids' Android phone from their iPhone.
Other issues that various apps addressed included weak coverage with Apple's tool, like how it only blocks content in the Safari web browser for mobile, not Chrome or others; or multiple users using the same device. You don't want your kid's limits set while you're on the same iPad.
UPDATE: April 29, 2019, 10:19 a.m. AEST Added a statement from Apple.
Sasha is a news writer at Mashable's San Francisco office. She's an SF native who went to UC Davis and later received her master's from the UC Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism. She's been reporting out of her hometown over the years at Bay City News (news wire), SFGate (the San Francisco Chronicle website), and even made it out of California to write for the Chicago Tribune. She's been described as a bookworm and a gym rat.
