The 12 best LGBTQ candidates for 'The Bachelor'

It's time to queer this heteronormative poison.
 By 
Heather Dockray
 on 
The 12 best LGBTQ candidates for 'The Bachelor'
Eichner has offered to be the American version's first queer contestant. Credit: Matt Baron/REX/Shutterstock

As a queer person, it's long been my dream to see my community represented in the lowest form of entertainment: The Bachelor.

On Wednesday, comedian Billy Eichner decided to rise to the challenge and offer himself up as fresh meat. "I actually do think it would be cool to do a gay season of The Bachelor," Eichner wrote, "and hey @BachelorABC, I'm single."

Eichner's tweet was met with non-ironic enthusiasm on Twitter. FYI, haters: The LGBTQ community likes trash corporate television like the rest of y'all. Just because it's heteronormative poison doesn't mean we're not on board! We, too, love passing fauxmances and manufactured drama between morons.

The time has come for queer and trans bachelor(ette)s to reclaim this cultural wasteland.

It's never been a better time for a queer bachelor. 2018 included multiple, painful queer breakups. And the Queer Eye guys showed the world they can be even more popular than the straights on streaming television. Even if you hate The Bachelor (highly understandable), queer representation matters, wherever you can find it.

Here are the queer and trans celebrities we believe are single (though of course these things can change) and could most benefit from a scripted romance:

1. Jonathan Van Ness

Via Giphy

Jonathan Van Ness is one of those rare celebrities who's loved both by the normies and the radical queers alike. We all grieved for Jonathan after his relationship ended with soccer player Wilco Froneman this winter. Now we all hope for the same thing for him: the opportunity to go an ice-skating date with a big ol' gay bear on broadcast television.

2. Amandla Sternberg

Via Giphy

Now that the arm wrestling posts have stopped, it's believed that queer couple King Princess and Amandla Sternberg has gone their separate ways. It's fine, it's not like we were depending on two 24-year-olds in the throes of young love for our personal happiness.

The Hate U Give star probably hates this show. We'd like to offer her the opportunity anyways.

3. King Princess

Listen, we're not taking sides in this breakup, okay? They're both very good on Instagram.

4. Hayley Kiyoko

Jesus might have been single, but "Lesbian Jesus" doesn't have to be. Just imagine the brutal take-down pop anthems she'll make when she inevitably dumps whatever silicone dud wins the show.

5. Trace Lysette

Mashable Image
Pantsuit goals Credit: Chelsea Lauren/REX/Shutterstock

This Transparent star and trans advocate is far too good for The Bachelorette or anything on network television, but in the event she feels like dipping her toe into our disgusting lowbrow universe, we're here.

6. Laith Ashley

Single or not, it doesn't matter: Everyone [who is good] wants this trans model and activist to achieve maximum possible representation. The world is a far hotter place because of him.

7. Keiynan Lonsdale

He's here, he's queer, and he could theoretically be single. Please sign this actor-singer-beautiful-human up.

8. Janelle Monaé

Mashable Image
Monae at the 76th Annual Golden Globe Awards Credit: Matt Baron/BEI/REX/Shutterstock

Based on recent interviews, it no longer appears that she and Tessa Thompson are dating one another. And unfortunately for Janelle, no one is good enough to be at her level. It'll be cute to watch her lessers try.

9. Abbi Jacobson

Abbi Jacobson came out as queer earlier this year and frankly it's all I've been able to think about since. Someone please put her on the show so I can get back to my normal life, aka googling other queer celebrities.

10. Alia Shawkat

Mashable Image
This is the face of someone who hates being on this list. Credit: Dave Allocca/Starpix/REX/Shutterstock

I can't think of anyone who would hate being on The Bachelor more than the incredibly talented and deeply, darkly funny Alia Shawkat. Still, good entertainment.

11. Nyle DiMarco

Mashable Image
Would watch 12 hungry men eat him alive Credit: Matt Baron/REX/Shutterstock

Male model Nyle DiMarco is rumored to be both single and kind. How rare a combination is that? Someone please find him love.

12. Billy Eichner

Via Giphy

Billy Eichner runs a good goddamn show and is one of the few smart people on Twitter. Most importantly, he's big and famous and he offered to do it.

Sorry, Michelle Obama. For some kinds of change, we need more people who are high to stoop low. That's just how this country works.

Topics LGBTQ

Mashable Image
Heather Dockray

Heather was the Web Trends reporter at Mashable NYC. Prior to joining Mashable, Heather wrote regularly for UPROXX and GOOD Magazine, was published in The Daily Dot and VICE, and had her work featured in Entertainment Weekly, Jezebel, Mic, and Gawker. She loves small terrible dogs and responsible driving. Follow her on Twitter @wear_a_helmet.

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
Grindr for lesbians? Here are the best dating apps for LGBTQ women.
illustration of woman giving flowers to another woman

Bachelor Nation, #MomTok furious over violent video of Taylor Frankie Paul
Reality star Taylor Frankie Paul at the Academy Awards in Los Angeles

Jimmy Kimmel breaks down the FCC's latest threat to talk shows
Jimmy Kimmel presents his show.

What is heteroflexibility? It's the highest-growing sexuality on Feeld.
illustration of pride flag, lips, and other symbols emerging from a computer screen

'Heated Rivalry' fans in Russia are breaking antigay laws to stream the show
Connor Storrie and Hudson Williams, stars of Heated Rivalry, pose with bottles of champagne.

More in Life
The Earth is glowing in new Artemis II pictures of home
One half of the Earth is seen floating in space through the open door of the Orion spacecraft.

Doomsday Clock now closest to midnight ever
A photograph of the Doomsday Clock, stating "It is 85 seconds to midnight."

Hurricane Erin: See spaghetti models and track the storm’s path online
A map showing the predicted path of Tropical Storm Erin.

Tropical Storm Erin: Spaghetti models track the storm’s path
A prediction cone for Tropical Storm Erin.

NASA to build a nuclear reactor on the moon by 2030, report states
The lunar surface.

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 3, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

Wordle today: Answer, hints for April 3, 2026
Wordle game on a smartphone

What's new to streaming this week? (April 3, 2026)
A composite of images from film and TV streaming this week.


NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 2, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!