People are baffled after someone said eating cereal with water is better than milk

What kind of monster would do this?
 By 
Sage Anderson
 on 
People are baffled after someone said eating cereal with water is better than milk
Oh boy, here we go. Credit: GETTY/ @DUBITABLYINDUBITABLE

There are a lot of unpopular opinions out there. Some are polarizing (I will go to my grave defending the honor of pineapple on pizza), while some takes aren't actually that controversial.

But every so often there is one opinion so devious, so purely evil, that it rises above the rest. I'm talking, of course, about eating cereal with water.

Redditor u/DubitablyIndubitable shared their beliefs on how this breakfast food should be eaten with a post that has since become the top of all time on the subreddit r/unpopularopinion.

The reaction was a swift and intense "thanks, I hate it!" This was compounded by the fact that he admitted he doesn't even drink the cereal water (two words that shouldn't be together), the same way you would drink the leftover cereal milk in the bowl.

"It's just for the texture it provides the cereal," the wrote.

What?

Via Giphy

The saga continues, when it turns out that he breaks another sacred rule of cereal-eating. Folks, this person pours the water (and I still can't believe this) first, and then pours the cereal.

While there seems to be no reason to disrespect cereal like this, u/DubitablyIndubitable responded to comments by saying that he "[doesn't] like milk and cereal is dry. Water is the logical solution." Reddit user u/Elimacc replied with "Dude, just like, pick a different breakfast. Instant oatmeal with water is fine." Agreed.

Even the moderator of the subreddit chimed in on the thread.

Although in the spirit of what the subreddit specifically asks for, many users were actually grateful that for once, this opinion was sincerely unpopular. Not prejudice thinly disguised as an "opinion," not political discourse, just genuinely a banal unpopular opinion.

And really, this is one that we can probably forgive. But peanut butter, ketchup, and pickle sandwich person is on thin ice.

Topics Reddit

Mashable Image
Sage Anderson

Sage is the newest Culture writer on the block at Mashable NYC. They recently graduated from Sarah Lawrence College, and have previously worked for The Dr. Oz Show, NorthSouth Productions, and on Netflix's 'The OA Part II'. Off the clock, they can be found testing out cupcake recipes, collecting dolls, and watching Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure for the millionth time.

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
'Pokémon Pokopia': How to get the Suck ability to move water around
Ditto in Pokemon Pokopia


Bad Bunny Super Bowl Halftime Show: What the football said
Bad Bunny holding a Puerto Rican flag.

The lonely state of getting over someone you never dated
A couple kisses on a subway train while the man reaches his hand out to a stranger nearby

AdultFriendFinder success rate: Real AFF info from someone who’s tried it
By Jack Dawes
Hands shaking surrounding by dice

More in Life
The Earth is glowing in new Artemis II pictures of home
One half of the Earth is seen floating in space through the open door of the Orion spacecraft.

Doomsday Clock now closest to midnight ever
A photograph of the Doomsday Clock, stating "It is 85 seconds to midnight."

Hurricane Erin: See spaghetti models and track the storm’s path online
A map showing the predicted path of Tropical Storm Erin.

Tropical Storm Erin: Spaghetti models track the storm’s path
A prediction cone for Tropical Storm Erin.

NASA to build a nuclear reactor on the moon by 2030, report states
The lunar surface.

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 3, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

Wordle today: Answer, hints for April 3, 2026
Wordle game on a smartphone

NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 4, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

Google launches Gemma 4, a new open-source model: How to try it
Google Gemma

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!