I've tested 100+ sex toys. Here are the 15 most mind-blowing toys I've ever owned.
If you’re looking for a new sex toy, you’ve come to the right place. Each product on this list was thoroughly vetted and reviewed by yours truly, so you can be confident in your purchase. I also consulted certified sex therapists, sexologists, and industry experts to back up my picks, but ultimately, the final selections come down to real-world use. After years of trial and error (and testing hundreds of products), these are the sex toys that earned a spot in my nightstand.
Overview
Table of Contents
My first sex toy ever was a cheap and super sketch dual-ended jelly dildo from Amazon (which, disturbingly, is still sold there today). To make matters worse, I had it shipped to my college mailroom, and it arrived in a package that literally looked like a shrink-wrapped sausage. I was mortified, but back then, I didn't know the difference between a "good deal" and a health hazard.
Since then, I’ve come a long way (pun intended). Because I have endometriosis, my relationship with pleasure — particularly penetration — is complicated, to say the least. Testing sex toys isn’t just a fun job perk (though it definitely is); it’s something I pushed my career into so that I could fix my sex life and find products that worked for my body. I have zero tolerance for anything that feels cheap or uncomfortable — which is a pretty good standard to have, anyway. While this list does include products for pelvic pain, like the Ohnut, there are plenty of options here for everyone and every body type.
I’m also testing out a few additional toys for inclusion in this guide. Particularly, the iconic Magic Wand (formerly Hitachi Magic Wand) and the all-gender njoy Pure Wand.
AdultFriendFinder — readers’ pick for casual connections
Hinge — popular choice for regular meetups
Tracy's Dog OG Sucking Vibrator
Best budget pick
The Good & The Bad
- Usually on sale for under $30
- Has 10 suction modes and 10 vibration patterns
- Comes in a proper box with foam, making it feel luxe
- The clitoral suction might be *too intense* for some people
- You have to be careful to fully dry the suction nozzle
- The OG doesn't come with a remote
- Harder to find this specific model on Amazon compared to other Tracy's Dog toys
Who it's for
This toy is specifically for people who crave intense clitoral suction (or dual stimulation) but don't want to spend $100+.
Being horny and on a budget is a dangerous combo. It can make you do crazy, stupid things — like buying a double-ended jelly dildo or a chemical-laden vibrator off Amazon. So, instead of roasting your bits, I recommend Tracy’s Dog OG Sucking Vibrator. If you can get past the name, this suction vibe is safe, effective, durable (I've had mine for at least five years), and almost always on sale for under $30. It doesn't feel cheap, either; it arrives in a nice box with foam padding, not some sad plastic bag.
Why we like it
The Tracy’s Dog OG is one of my absolute favorite toys. I keep this sucker (ha) in my nightstand, charged and ready to go. And, as I mentioned earlier, I have endometriosis, so I was genuinely relieved to find that the internal arm doesn’t bother me as much as some stiff vibrators do — it offers fullness without the pain.
Fair warning, though: This thing is intense. Do not start on high. Work your way up slowly through the 10 suction and vibration modes. Because it's so flexible, it also makes for a surprisingly great addition when you’re giving your partner head. (Yes, the newer OG 2 has a remote, but I’m telling you: the original is still the better buy.)
One quick maintenance tip: When cleaning it, make sure you dry the little suction nozzle completely. Water loves to get trapped in there, so give it a good shake or let it air-dry face down. It's also a dog-hair magnet, so if you have fur babies (I have two), just be sure to keep it in an enclosed place (or the box it came in).
Not only that, but this vibe is famous. (If you haven't read the reviews, you def should.) It pretty much broke the internet in 2019 when a reviewer wrote that her “soul left her body” and “God himself” spoke to her. While I can’t promise you’ll have a religious experience, I can definitely say that this little toy has always gotten me there.
Looking for a higher-end version of this toy? I recommend the LELO Enigma Double Sonic.
Details
ZALO Bess 2 Clitoral Massager
Best luxury vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- Gold plating and "Softek" coating make it display-worthy
- Comes with four attachments, including an anal beads attachment
- Warms up to 107 degrees F (42 degrees C) for a realistic feel
- Includes a storage bag and warranty card
- It's definitely a splurge
- The clitoral tip is quiet, but the handle gets buzzy/loud
Who it's for
The Bess 2 clitoral massager is for the aesthete who refuses to hide their sex toys in a dark drawer. (Good for you!) If you have the budget and want a vibe that doubles as modern art, ZALO is the brand to go to.
Sure, LELO sells some incredible luxury toys (and I mention them below), but ZALO takes "luxe" to a completely different level — think gold plating, real Swarovski crystal accents, and innovative features.
Why we like it
ZALO is luxe AF, full stop. But it’s not just a gimmick. I can vouch for this brand’s commitment to quality; it even arrives with a satin storage pouch and an authenticity warranty card, so you know it’s a true investment piece.
The Bess 2 earned its place on this list for its ability to set your clit on fire in the best way possible. (Bess? More like Bless.) It features "Double Tungsten Motors" and ZALO's exclusive "Softek" silicone coating, which gives it that impossibly soft, skin-like feel.
It comes with four attachments, including a slim curved shaft and "soft petals," but my personal favorite is the ball-shaped head. Thanks to the "DirectPower technology," it delivers pinpoint stimulation that gets the job done in seconds. You can also preheat this baby to 107 degrees Fahrenheit (it mimics body heat in a way cold silicone just can't) for an extra-smooth ride.
A few notes from testing: While the pinpoint clitoral side is impressively quiet, the wider end (where the main motor lives) can get a little noisy on higher settings. Also, like many silicone toys, the soft finish attracts dog hair, sheet fuzz, lint, etc. Fortunately, it’s super easy to wipe clean, and if you keep it in that storage bag, it should be fine.
One of my favorite reviews says, “Get on setting three, and you will be astral projecting to another realm” — something to think about if squirting is on your 2026 bucket list.
Want something that's even more precise? Check out Zumio.
Details
LELO Smart Wand 2 Large
Best wand vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- Extremely intense vibrations for those who need speed
- Easier to hold than the classic "heavy" wands
- Lasts for hours on a single charge
- Certified body-safe materials (ISO 3533)
- The charging cord is short
- If you prefer deep, thudding rumbles, this might be too buzzy/intense for you
- It’s an investment (but look for sales)
Who it's for
The LELO Smart Wand 2 Large is for anyone who wants to get off, like right now, and doesn’t mind paying a little extra to do so.
It’s a luxe vibrator, and that's reflected in the price — but you’ll also feel it in the function. This wand is super intense (read: NOT RUMBLY) and offers 10 different vibration patterns. While some say having too many options is a con, I personally like to just hold it on the consistent vibration setting and see where it gets me.
Why we like it
First, I’d like to preface this by saying that my actual favorite wand (and probably my favorite vibrator of all time) was the VIM by Fun Factory. But sadly, it’s discontinued, and I wouldn't trust the third-party sellers on Amazon who claim to have it.
Nevertheless, before I met the VIM, my favorite was the LELO Smart Wand 2 Large. It costs a little more than the ZALO toy mentioned above, but it’s definitely worth it. (Also, LELO often has sales, so you rarely have to pay full price anyway.)
The main thing to know is that, unlike many "rumbly" wands, the Smart Wand 2 is intense and super powerful in a buzzy way. It has an ergonomic design and an extra-long-lasting charge — you can literally play with it for hours, if your body can handle it.
I love the design because it’s easier to hold than most competitors. I own a few wands, and most are too heavy for my wrist. I have carpal tunnel (from typing; get your mind out of the gutter), and holding other toys for testing actually hurts. (Note: If you find standard wands are still too heavy for your wrist, you might prefer the FemmeFunn Ultra Wand instead; they put a special dampener in the handle specifically to prevent that vibration recoil.)
The Smart Wand 2 is also super pretty as far as vibrators go. It arrives in a beautiful white box and is ISO 3533 international standard certified, which means it’s proven safe to use on your intimate bits. It also comes with a storage bag for safekeeping.
Looking for something smaller? I recommend the Koi by love. not war.
Details
Playboy Pleasure Ollo
Best bullet vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- The handle keeps the vibration on your body, not your hand
- The flat tip hits exactly where you need it
- Powerful, rechargeable, and waterproof for under $50
- Easier to hold than slippery chrome bullets
- At nearly six inches, it's not as "pocket-sized" as a mini bullet
Who it's for
The Playboy Pleasure Ollo is for anyone who wants to like a bullet vibrator but needs a little more power, versatility, and ergonomic comfort than a typical compact design provides.
I don’t really like bullet vibrators, mainly because I don’t like how they feel in my hand. I don’t particularly like my fingers buzzing right along with the toy — it’s uncomfortable (to me). But the Ollo is the perfect bullet vibrator for the non-bullet vibrator lover. It has a handle and all the power you could want in a tiny little package.
Why we like it
Playboy Pleasure is by far one of my favorite sex toy brands. I love several of their products (which you’ll see further down my list), but the Ollo isn’t your typical bullet.
It's longer (5.74 inches) and designed with an ergonomic "ring" handle. This makes it so much easier, IMO, to use than a traditional bullet. (Take the Playboy Pleasure Bunny Bunch, for example. I love the power it has, but it’s so powerful it gets hot when I use it for too long, and the vibration is all in my fingertips.) The Ollo solves this with its grip-friendly design and a flat, lipstick-shaped tip that's ideal for pinpoint clitoral stimulation.
It has 10 speeds and rhythms, it’s waterproof, and it's USB rechargeable. Short, sweet, and to the point. It doesn’t come with a fancy sack or over-the-top packaging, but for under $50, it delivers a powerful experience and is made of body-safe silicone (a huge plus at this price point).
Details
Smile Makers The Firefighter
Best clit vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- Perfect for sensitive or larger clits that need broader stimulation
- Great for external massage or very shallow internal play
- Thoughtfully designed for female pleasure first
- If you're a "power user" who needs intense speed, this might be too soft
- The charging hole is tricky to locate
- Only six total settings (four speeds, two pulses)
Who it's for
This vibe is for anyone who’s looking for a clit vibrator that won’t overstimulate and yet is still powerful enough to get you off.
Its unique design is incredibly thoughtful — this brand genuinely prioritizes female anatomy, and you can tell this vibe was built for the vulva, not just marketed to it.
Why we like it
Smile Makers' The Firefighter (an ironic name, since we definitely aren't trying to put any fires out) is an expertly designed stimulator built to pleasure the entire vulva, not just the button.
It feels so, so good just resting on your clit and moving over your labia. The flame-shaped head is designed for gentle, precise stimulation rather than aggressive buzzing. Once you’re wet enough, you can even let the tip peek in and out for the shallowest, most delicious penetration you’ve ever experienced.
It features four speeds and two pulsation modes, and it's super quiet. It isn’t over-the-top or feature-rich, but that’s another thing I love about Smile Makers: They know you can get to the finish line without all the bells and whistles. (One small note: The charging hole is almost too discreet. It can be kind of hard to find at first because it blends right into the silicone, so you might need good lighting to plug it in the first time.)
When I say this gives "Big Clit Energy," that’s not just a line. This isn’t the intense, numbing vibration you’re used to hearing about (there are plenty of those elsewhere on this list). This is the "slow burn" kind of pleasure that feels oh-so-good solo or while making out with a partner.
Details
The Good & The Bad
- Looks like a piece of fruit or decor, not a sex toy
- Famous for delivering quick, intense orgasms
- Simple controls and a non-intimidating shape
- Comes with thoughtful extras like lube and cleaner.
- It really only does one thing (suction)
- Often sells out due to viral fame
Who it's for
The Lem is the best clitoral sucker for anyone who's new to this type of stimulation or just wants a more discreet option.
Despite its super cute exterior, this little toy doesn’t hold back — it delivers intense clitoral stimulation. It's ideal for beginners or anyone who doesn't respond to vibration alone (whether due to menopause, medication, or personal preference).
Why we like it
The Lem is probably the cutest sex toy I’ve ever seen; it literally looks like a lemon, hence the name. But don’t let the playful appearance fool you — its air pulse technology is incredibly powerful, but somehow soft and gentle at the same time. There are 12 intensities and patterns to explore (I couldn’t even use it on the highest setting), it’s very easy to hold, and it’s quieter than I expected.
It’s also shipped in a cute pink box with a USB charging cable, a silky storage pouch, a user manual, and a small packet of lube and toy cleaner.
One of my favorite reviews says, “Holy mother of God! I can’t put this little sucker down. I am getting multiple orgasms with this little guy, and last night, I actually squirted! I didn’t even think that was a real thing…but I’m here to tell you, IT IS!”
Before I fell in love with the Lem, the Namii by biird was my go-to; I loved it. I was actually obsessed with their packaging and how thoughtful the whole unboxing experience felt. But biird recently took it (and all its other clitoral stimulators) off the site without warning. So, the next best thing I’ve tested is the Lem by Nancy. (Another kind of odd name, I know).
Details
Playboy Pleasure The Swan
Best dual stimulation vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- Ideal for double penetration
- The bulbous heads provide specific, targeted pressure
- 10 speeds per shaft means you can customize the intensity for each area
- You have to be hyper-vigilant about cleaning it to avoid cross-contamination
Who it's for
This is for the person who can’t decide between a rabbit, a wand, or a dildo — and doesn't want to clutter their nightstand with all three. If you want one high-quality toy that can switch gears from "mild and rumbly" to "mind-blowing" in seconds, I def recommend The Swan.
Why we like it
It’s hard to play favorites, but The Swan has earned a permanent spot on my nightstand since the day I unboxed it. It’s a dual stimulator with two gently curved arms, designed to do pretty much whatever you want. You can use it for standard clitoral and G-spot stimulation, or flip it around for simultaneous anal and vaginal play. (Just remember not to cross-contaminate!)
I’m not the only one obsessed with its versatility, either — reviewers consistently rate this as a top pick for double penetration (DP) because the flexible arms make dual entry surprisingly accessible. Each shaft has 10 vibrating speeds and bulbous, textured heads that work for both internal and external play. You can use it solely on the outside to finish in seconds, or use it for a deep, blended orgasm.
Details
JimmyJane Apex
Best pussy pump vibrator
The Good & The Bad
- It’s a pump, a vibrator, and an oral simulator in one
- The clear chamber lets you (or a partner) watch the show
- Comes with cups for both vulva and nipples
- Great for long, intense sessions
- High risk of injury if you don't know what you're doing
- Both the pump and the tongue attachment are VERY loud
- Definitely not a "starter" toy
Who it's for
The Apex by JimmyJane is for experienced users only. I repeat: This thing can be dangerous if you use it incorrectly.
It’s for people who can’t get enough sensation, or for those who love exhibitionism (or have a partner into voyeurism). This pussy pump is a vibrator, clitoral stimulator, and suction device rolled into one intense package.
Why we like it
Most pussy pumps don't function as traditional sex toys, but the Apex by JimmyJane is a G-spot vibrator, clitoral and nipple stimulator, and of course, a pussy pump.
This toy looks a little intimidating, and it should. It’s designed for advanced players; using this improperly or not testing it on your hand first could definitely lead to discomfort or injury. The actual pump is amazingly powerful (it’s also really loud, as is the tongue attachment), but once you actually figure out how to use it, it’s definitely worth pulling out once a month for a sex marathon.
The best thing about this toy is that your partner can watch your vulva fill the plastic chamber and swell to impressive proportions. Not only that, but paired with the tongue attachment, it’s an experience unlike any other. There are seven tongue patterns, 10 handle vibration patterns, and three suction levels. There are also two cup attachments (one for your vulva and one for your nipples).
Details
FemmeFunn Thruster Shaft
Best thruster
The Good & The Bad
- Thrusts don't stall, even against muscle contractions
- Strong suction base allows for creative positioning
- Easy to adjust settings mid-play
- Perfect for hitting the G-spot or P-spot
- The realistic shape might not be for everyone
- Needs a smooth surface and some space to work best
Who it's for
The FemmeFunn Thruster Shaft is for anyone who has the time and space to giddy up and get off. It’s designed for deep vaginal and G-spot stimulation (though it can definitely be used for anal play, too).
Why we like it
I’ve never been a huge fan of thrusters (mostly because my endometriosis hasn’t exactly let me enjoy deep penetration for years), but on a good day, the FemmeFunn Thruster Shaft is my go-to.
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: If you want to get there, this is the thruster you want.
This toy delivers serious power and deep thrusting motions that keep going even as your muscles contract, so it won’t freeze up on you right when you get to the good part. It has a suction cup base that’ll attach to just about anything (a headboard, the side of a bathtub, a chair, the floor, etc.); just don’t try to attach it to a mirror.
I definitely recommend getting on all fours (put a pillow under your knees for comfort) and seeing what this baby can do. It has a remote so you can control just how intense it gets (or you can give it to your partner and let them take control). The remote also makes it easy to adjust settings while you’re playing, so you don’t have to reach down or mess with the controls and ruin the moment.
The only thing I don’t love about this toy is that it actually looks like a penis, which isn’t ideal for everyone. But it does come in purple (I have the dark purple one, which is the brand’s signature color) if the flesh tones freak you out.
Details
Lovers Loyal 5.5in Dildo
Best dildo
The Good & The Bad
- Shockingly soft and pliable, which is great if you hate rigid toys
- Works as a suction mount or just an easy-to-hold handle
- At 5.5 inches, it’s manageable but satisfying
- The base is wide enough to stay put in a strap-on
- It looks very realistic (veins and all), which isn't for everyone
Who it's for
The Lovers Loyal 5.5in Dildo is for anyone who prefers internal stimulation without the vibration. It’s also the perfect option if you need a softer touch (literally). As I mentioned, I’m not always up for rigid penetration due to pelvic pain, but this is the dildo I reach for when I am.
Why we like it
This little guy is super soft (like, unbelievably soft) and flexible. It has a suction cup base similar to the thruster above, so you can stick it to the floor, the shower wall, or a chair for hands-free play. But honestly, I mostly use the suction base as a handle; it gives you a great grip if you don't want to mount it to anything.
It’s 5.5 inches long and harness-compatible. The veins and flesh tone can be a turn-off if you prefer abstract shapes, but I assure you, the comfort level here makes it worth it. (Plus, the size and flexibility make it a solid option for anal play, too.)
Details
Playboy Pleasure Jewels King Multi-Play Glass Dildo
Best glass dildo
The Good & The Bad
- Heavy, smooth, and incredibly filling
- Great for heating up or cooling down
- Shatter-resistant glass (with a warranty to back it up)
- Non-porous and super easy to clean
- There's zero "give," so if you prefer squishy toys, skip this
Who it's for
The Playboy Pleasure Jewels King is for anyone who prefers the hard, heavy feel of glass over the squishy feel of silicone. It’s specifically for those moments when you want to be completely filled up (and want a toy that looks good doing it).
Why we like it
If you’ve yet to experience what an absolute delight glass toys can be, I recommend giving the Playboy Pleasure Jewels King Multi-Play Glass Dildo a try ASAP.)
This toy has everything you want in a dildo. The super-smooth, body-safe borosilicate glass is easy to clean, and the bulbous head (which is curved just right) feels delicious whether you’re using it vaginally or anally. I also love the length (5.5 insertable inches) and thickness.
It’s also pretty to look at and shatter-resistant. I’ve accidentally dropped it a few times, and it’s yet to crack or chip. (If you do manage to break it, it comes with a five-year manufacturer’s warranty.) And if you’re into temperature play, you can pop it in some warm or cool water for a few minutes beforehand.
Details
Le Wand Arch
Best stainless steel dildo
The Good & The Bad
- It’s famous for making people squirt
- You can choose between the girthy, rippled end or the slimmer, flat tip
- The weight adds a unique sensation you don't get with traditional silicone toys
- Unlike silicone, you can use any lube you want
- It's heavy (nearly 2 lbs), so watch out if you have wrist issues
- It feels very big, so use plenty of lube!
- Cold to the touch unless you warm it up
Who it's for
If you like the feeling of glass, you'll love stainless steel. But fair warning: It's heavy (1.87 lbs). This might not be best for people with weak wrists, arthritis, or mobility limitations.
If you're looking for P-spot stimulation instead of G-spot stimulation, then go with the similar Njoy Pure Wand stainless-steel dildo instead.
Why we like it
I'm definitely not the only one who recommends the Le Wand Arch; a lot of sexperts swear by this thing, specifically because it's ahhmazing for squirting.
The crescent-shaped, double-ended design allows you to apply hard, unyielding pressure to the G-spot in a way flexible plastic toys just can't. One end has a rippled texture for massage, and the other has a flattened tip for targeted G-spot stimulation. Plus, it comes with a high-quality padded pouch so you don't have to worry about it clanking around (or chipping) in your nightstand.
Since it's dual-ended, you don't have to use the girthy side if you don't want to. If you do use the larger end, just know it's really girthy. You may need to be warmed up a lot for this one.
Stainless steel is also prized for hygiene (you can literally boil this or put it in the dishwasher) and temperature play. One major rule, though: Lube is a non-negotiable for stainless steel unless you are super, super wet before insertion.
Details
b-Vibe Beginner’s Vibrating Butt Plug
Best butt plug
The Good & The Bad
- At just 1.1 inches wide, it's super approachable and beginner-friendly
- Made of smooth, high-quality silicone
- Flared base ensures safety (a must for anal toys)
- If you're an experienced user, this might feel too small
- It’s an investment compared to non-vibrating starter plugs
Who it's for
This is the perfect entry point for anyone curious about anal play. If you're intimidated by size or just want something that feels approachable rather than ambitious, the b-Vibe Beginner’s Vibrating Butt Plug is a great place to start.
Why we like it
I personally love the Playboy Pleasure Glass Butt Plug (or The Neighbor by Smile Makers) because I prefer a rounder, fuller size. But that doesn't mean you'll love it, especially if you're a beginner. For most people, I recommend the b-Vibe Beginner’s Vibrating Butt Plug.
It's designed specifically for beginners, with a petite 1.1-inch diameter and a manageable 3-inch insertable length. It’s made of body-safe silicone and has a seamless shape that makes insertion much less scary.
Plus, it vibrates! Which not only helps to relax your muscles (very important for anal play), but it also adds a ton of sensation for your partner if you wear it during sex.
Details
TENGA EGG
Best male sex toy
The Good & The Bad
- A low-stakes way to try toys without the investment
- The material stretches to fit almost any size
- Dozens of textures to try (Standard, Hard Boiled, etc.)
- Very affordable way to experiment with textures
- You have to toss it after one go, so it's not the most eco-friendly toy
Who it's for
The TENGA EGG is for anyone with a penis who wants a low-commitment, high-reward experience (i.e., anyone who wants to ease into male sex toys without spending a fortune on a high-tech masturbator or sleeve). It's also great for partners who want to amp up their handjob game.
Why we like it
Hands down, this is the best male sex toy for the price. You can buy them individually for $6.99 or in variety packs of six for $41.94 (like the "Hard Boiled" or "Wonder" packs), and they're incredibly easy to use.
Each egg has a unique internal texture (like "Wavy," "Clicker," or "Spider") lined with intricate ribs, nubs, and geometric patterns that create 360-degree friction and suction you just can't get with a hand alone. The material is super-stretchable; for reference, it can stretch to cover a 500ml plastic bottle, so size is almost never an issue.
Bonus: They're disposable. You crack the shell, use the included lube packet, enjoy yourself, and then toss it. It’s mess- and hassle-free.
Details
Ohnut Depth-Limiting Rings
Best for painful sex
The Good & The Bad
- Doctor-recommended
- HSA/FSA eligible
- You can stack the rings to choose exactly how much buffer you need
- The material is super stretchy, soft, and body-safe (BPA- and phthalate-free)
- It feels comfortable for the wearer, too
- At $75, it is an investment for essentially four rings
- You must use plenty of lube; it won't work without it (and will probably make things even worse)
Who it's for
The Ohnut is specifically designed for anyone who experiences pain during deep penetration. Whether you have endometriosis, pelvic floor issues, or are going through postpartum recovery, this little barrier will help you keep the intimacy alive.
Why we like it
I was actually one of the very first people to try the Ohnut when it launched, and I’m not exaggerating when I say it saved my relationship at the time. I still use my original set — in fact, I’ve had them for so long that the polymer has actually changed color over the years. I honestly have no idea why (I kept them in a black storage bag the whole time!), but they shifted from the original mint green to the blue you see in my photos.
If you have endometriosis, interstitial cystitis (I have this, too), struggle with pelvic floor dysfunction, or any of the other reasons for dyspareunia, the Ohnut is worth looking into. It works as a physical bumper. It’s a set of four soft, stackable rings that sit at the base of a penis (or toy) to limit how deep it can go.
Because it’s made of a soft, squishy polymer that feels like skin, it doesn't feel like a medical device. You can customize the depth (by adding or removing rings) to your comfort level so you can stop bracing for impact (anticipatory pain is the worst) and stay in the moment.
Details
Topics Sex Toys
What to look for when buying sex toys
Walking into a sex shop (or browsing the web) can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re a first timer. There are just so many options to choose from, and if you’re not sure what you’re looking for, it can get confusing (and expensive!) fast.
After testing hundreds of products and consulting with the experts, I’ve boiled it down to a few non-negotiables.
Material matters (do the sniff test).
If there’s one rule you follow, let it be this: No mystery rubber or jelly materials. If the specific materials aren’t listed or you’re actually in the store and it smells like a chemical fire or a new car tire, put it down.
“Look for medical-grade silicone, stainless steel, or glass,” Emily Lambert Robins, LCSW, and AASECT-certified sex therapist, tells Mashable. These materials are generally non-porous and easy to clean. Robins also suggests avoiding materials such as PVC, jelly rubber, and anything containing phthalates.
Start simple.
It’s tempting to buy the most advanced or aesthetic toy with multiple vibration modes and app connectivity, but more features don’t always mean more pleasure. Honestly, I’m not a fan of the toys with all the bells and whistles because if I press the wrong button or have to fumble with an app, I will lose interest fast!
“Start simple, stay curious, and stay true to yourself,” advises Sarah Kelleher, LCSW, and sex and relationship therapist. “Ask yourself: What kind of stimulation am I most drawn to? Internal? External? Gentle? Intense? That kind of self-awareness is more helpful than any recommended list,” she adds. “Your first toy doesn’t need to be the most powerful or high-tech — it needs to feel approachable, whatever that means to you.”
Buy toys that work with your body, not against it.
It’s easy to get caught up in marketing hype or friendly recommendations (or even things you see in porn), but one of the most important things to remember is that you’re buying this toy for your body. Therefore, it should work with your body, not against it. (This is something I learned the hard way.)
“The biggest mistake to avoid is buying based on popularity alone or buying based on what you want or wish your body to feel/do/or like instead of based on what it does or what you like currently,” says Kelleher. “That’s not to say don’t be curious and be open to expanding your horizons, but knowing and acknowledging your body and what feels good or not needs to be accounted for when purchasing a toy.”
According to board-certified sex therapist and sexuality educator at Hily: Dating app, Mindy DeSeta, PhD, this includes “comfortable grips, intuitive controls, appropriate sizing, and shapes that complement natural anatomy.”
Final note: Don’t forget the lube.
Finding the right lube can make all the difference, especially when you’re experimenting with penetration, vaginally or anally. But not all lubes are compatible with sex toys. Here’s a quick guide to help you choose the best lube:
Water-based lubes are the gold standard — they’re compatible with sex toys and condoms, and they’re super easy to clean up.
Silicone-based lubes aren’t compatible with silicone toys, but you can use them with latex condoms.
Oil-based lubes are long-lasting, but they’re not compatible with latex products (i.e., condoms) and can stain fabrics.
Flavored lubes are great for oral sex, but you really shouldn’t use these for vaginal or anal penetration, even if they’re water-based.
Frequently Asked Questions
First, click out of Amazon. As I learned the hard way, you do not want to roll the dice on mystery vendors. Anna Richards, sexologist and founder of FrolicMe, suggests shopping at women-owned retailers like Good Vibrations or Babeland, where the selection is curated for quality. Other trustworthy retailers include Lovehoney, Lovers, and all the brand-name stores like LELO, Dame, and unbound babes.
As for the toy itself, don’t get distracted by bells and whistles. Richards advises against buying anything "too elaborate" or "gimmicky" for your first time — a basic vibrator under $100 is usually the sweet spot.
Paul Aaron Travis, a certified sexologist and founder of School For Lovers, adds that beginners should look for toys with "adjustable intensities" rather than "all-or-nothing power" so you can figure out what you like without overwhelming your nervous system.
Yes, but you have to frame it right. A lot of partners worry they’ll be replaced by a piece of silicone, but Travis notes that relationship satisfaction is actually highest when toys are treated as "shared tools for play rather than as substitutes." If you want to bring a toy into the bedroom, start with something that's designed for two.
Richards recommends the We-Vibe Chorus, which is hands-free and allows both partners to feel the vibration. If that feels too advanced, check out a finger vibrator like the Dioni by FemmeFunn or the Fin by Dame.
Because you generally get what you pay for — but that doesn't mean you have to drop a whole paycheck to be safe. You can absolutely find high-quality, body-friendly options at retailers like Lovehoney or Good Vibes for under $50.
The real red flag isn't necessarily the low price tag; it's the material. Richards warns that "cheap toys" often rely on "jellies" or porous rubbers that can harbor bacteria. Travis backs this up, emphasizing that sticking to "medical-grade silicone" or borosilicate glass protects your health by preventing irritation and infection.
Basically, if a toy costs less than your lunch, there’s a reason. Save up for the safer option.
Over the years, I’ve tested hundreds of products, from drug store bullets to high-end luxury vibes. But I didn't just want to rely on my own trial and error. To make sure these picks are legit, I interviewed a panel of certified pros to confirm which materials are actually safe and why certain designs work better than others.
The Experts:
Anna Richards, sexologist and founder of FrolicMe
Emily Lambert Robins, LCSW, and AASECT-certified sex therapist
Mindy DeSeta, PhD, board-certified sex therapist and sexuality educator at Hily: Dating app
Paul Aaron Travis, certified sexologist and founder of School For Lovers
Sarah Kelleher, LCSW, and sex and relationship therapist
Tabitha Britt is an award-winning freelance journalist, editor, and SEO/AEO strategist. Aside from reviewing dating apps and sex toys for Mashable, Tabitha is also the founding editor-in-chief of DO YOU ENDO — a digital magazine by individuals with endometriosis, for individuals with endometriosis. She has a Master's degree in Creative Publishing and Critical Journalism from The New School for Social Research and is a grad of Sextech School. You can find more of her work in various online publications, including National Geographic, Glamour, Better Homes & Gardens, and Everyday Health.