'American Idol' is returning, but Kelly Clarkson and Simon Cowell are not

The top dawgs aren't coming back.
 By 
Nicole Gallucci
 on 
'American Idol' is returning, but Kelly Clarkson and Simon Cowell are not
Credit: Mashable composite: Kevin Winter/ getty images

American Idol is returning from the dead, but its top dawgs, Kelly Clarkson and Simon Cowell aren't coming along for the ride.

While there was originally some speculation that Clarkson, the OG Idol, would be brought onboard the show's 16th season, Clarkson will not be returning to her reality show roots to judge right away. In fact, Variety reported on Thursday that the singer will be joining NBC’s The Voice as a Season 14 coach. The ultimate betrayal.

And in case that didn't sting enough, Simon Cowell — one of Idol's original three judges — says we can count him out for the revival, too.

Clarkson's season of The Voice is set to premiere in February 2018, which means she could very well be going into a head-to-head ratings battle with Idol's expected March 2018 debut.

"I’m so excited to join," Clarkson told Variety. "We’ve gone back and forth about a role as a coach for years, but the timing hasn’t been right until now."

Drama.

She's not the only Idol alum who will be turning chairs with current Voice judges Blake Shelton and Adam Levine. Oscar-winning actress and singer, Jennifer Hudson — who was on American Idol back in 2004 — will be a coach on Season 13 of The Voice.

As for the lack of love surrounding the Idol revival, Cowell — now on America's Got Talent — told Extra that the show has changed far too much for him to return. "My memories are when we first started. It was a different time with Randy [Jackson], Ryan [Seacrest] and Paula [Abdul]. You can’t recreate that," he said. "Last time I watched, it was not the same show, just the same name. I left for a reason and I never regretted that."

"I was asked to do it, and the answer is no," he said bluntly. "I have no interest."

And Seacrest, who was Idol's host for 15 seasons, recently joined Kelly Ripa as her new Live co-host, so whether he'll be returning is still unclear. Basically, it seems as though everyone originally involved in the show has moved on, and even the response from fans hasn't been very positive.

Perhaps Idol can try to snag Season 1 runner up Justin Guarini away from whatever the heck he's up to right now ... or the very least, William Hung.

Mashable Image
Nicole Gallucci

Nicole is a Senior Editor at Mashable. She primarily covers entertainment and digital culture trends, and in her free time she can be found watching TV, sending voice notes, or going viral on Twitter for admiring knitwear. You can follow her on Twitter @nicolemichele5.

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
'Wonder Man' review: All hail the MCU's latest bromance
Ben Kingsley and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in "Wonder Man."


Connor Storrie, Hudson Williams, and Seventeen's Joshua are the Golden Globes' most viral meet-cute
A side-by-side image of Connor Storrie and Hudson Williams presenting at the Golden Globes and Joshua Hong on the red carpet

The best romantic comedies now streaming on Hulu
Scenes from "Fire Island," "Waiting to Exhale," "Happiest Season," and "Rye Lane."

Bart Layton on how 'Crime 101' compares to 'The Imposter' and 'American Animals'
Bart Layton attends the world premiere of Amazon MGM Studios' "Crime 101" at The United Theater on Broadway on Feb. 10, 2026 in Los Angeles, California.

More in Entertainment
California just launched the country's largest public broadband network
Newsom stands behind a teen on a computer. A group of people cheer and clap behind them.

The Shark FlexStyle is our favorite Dyson Airwrap dupe, and it's $160 off at Amazon right now
The Shark FlexStyle Air Styling & Drying System against a colorful background.

Amazon's sister site is having a one-day sale, and this Bissell TurboClean deal is too good to skip
A woman using the Bissell TurboClean Cordless Hard Floor Cleaner Mop and Lightweight Wet/Dry Vacuum.

The best smartwatch you've never heard of is on sale for less than $50
Nothing CMF Watch 3 Pro in light green with blue and green abstract background

Reddit r/all takes another step into the grave
Reddit logo on phone screen

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for April 3, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

Wordle today: Answer, hints for April 3, 2026
Wordle game on a smartphone

Google launches Gemma 4, a new open-source model: How to try it
Google Gemma

You can track Artemis II in real time as Orion flies to the moon
Victor Glover and Reid Wiseman piloting the Orion spacecraft

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
These newsletters may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. By clicking Subscribe, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!